My Honest Review of The Black Stuff All Natural Bar Soap (2025)

When it comes to grooming products, I’ve always been a bit skeptical of the hype around “all-natural” soaps. But after hearing about The Black Stuff All Natural Bar Soap, I was intrigued. This soap is handcrafted in Ireland and marketed primarily toward men who appreciate high-quality, natural grooming products. The company prides itself on using pure essential oils and avoiding synthetic chemicals, which is a big draw for anyone conscious about what they put on their skin.

With a growing interest in switching to more natural alternatives, I decided to try their Atlantic Pine Tar variety. Did it live up to the buzz? Here’s my honest take, covering everything from the scent to the effectiveness.

old packaging of the black stuff soap atlantic pine tar scent

Packaging

One of the first things I noticed about The Black Stuff soap was its minimalist packaging. The soap comes wrapped in recyclable paper or cardboard, keeping things simple and environmentally friendly. There’s a small square-shaped hole in the packaging that allows you to see the soap’s color before you buy it, which is a nice touch for those who like to know exactly what they’re getting.

The design is masculine and straightforward, with a black-and-white theme that reflects the brand’s aesthetic. I found this approach refreshing—no flashy designs or unnecessary frills, just a clean, functional presentation.

Another plus is that the packaging includes all the necessary information, like the ingredient list and company details. It’s clear that the brand values transparency, which is always a good sign.

However, I would have loved to see a bit more information on the specific benefits of each soap variety right on the packaging. While simplicity is great, a little more detail wouldn’t hurt.

Ingredients

The ingredients are where The Black Stuff really stands out. This soap is made with all-natural ingredients and is completely free of synthetic chemicals, which is ideal for anyone with sensitive skin or those looking to avoid harsh additives.

Some key ingredients include:

  • Shea Butter: Known for its moisturizing properties.
  • Olive Oil: Helps keep the skin hydrated and soft.
  • Pure Essential Oils: Provide natural scents without the need for artificial fragrances.

One thing that really impressed me is that the soap is vegan-friendly and palm oil-free. For those concerned about ethical sourcing and animal welfare, this is a huge plus. It’s also handmade in small batches in Ireland, which adds a personal touch to each bar.

While the company doesn’t go into great detail about the source of their ingredients, the emphasis on natural, high-quality components is evident. They also use the cold process method to make their soap, which is known for preserving the benefits of the ingredients.

Scent

Scent can make or break a bar soap for me, and I was pleasantly surprised by The Black Stuff’s fragrance offerings. I tried the Atlantic Pine Tar variety, and the scent was unlike anything I’ve encountered before.

The first whiff was a refreshing blend of lavender and mint, with just a hint of pine tar. It instantly transported me to a walk through a forest after a light rain—a calming and rejuvenating experience. The aroma isn’t overpowering; instead, it’s subtle yet noticeable. I appreciated that the scent felt natural and calming, evoking a sense of tranquility without the artificial, chemical-heavy smell you often get from commercial soaps.

What stood out most was the longevity of the scent. Even after a long day, I could still catch traces of the fragrance on my skin, particularly around my wrists and neck, which was a pleasant surprise. However, I did notice that the scent diminished more quickly on areas like my arms and torso after stepping out of the shower, leaving me wishing it had a more consistent presence throughout the day.

The company offers other interesting scent options like Irish Mountain Rain and The Celtic Tiger, each inspired by Ireland’s natural landscapes. It’s clear they’ve put a lot of thought into creating unique scent profiles that appeal to their target audience.

Effectiveness

Effectiveness is where The Black Stuff really shines. I found that the soap lathered easily and created a thick, creamy foam that made my showers feel more luxurious.

One of the standout features was how well it cleansed without leaving any residue. I’ve tried natural soaps before that left my skin feeling tight or dry, but this one was hydrating and gentle. Thanks to the shea butter and olive oil, my skin felt soft and moisturized after each use.

new packaging of the black stuff soap irish mountain rain scent

The Atlantic Pine Tar soap also has mild exfoliating properties, thanks to the inclusion of pumice and oatmeal. This made it ideal for scrubbing away dead skin without being too harsh. I found it particularly useful for areas like elbows and knees, which tend to get rougher.

Another thing worth mentioning is the soap’s deodorizing ability. I felt fresh throughout the day, even after a workout. It’s also beard-friendly, as my husband noted, and he found that it worked well for cleansing and softening facial hair.

That said, if you have very dry or sensitive skin, you might want to test it out before fully committing, as the exfoliating properties could be a bit much for some.

Size and Lifespan

The Black Stuff bar soaps come in a standard size of around 4.75 to 5 ounces (135 to 140 grams). This is comparable to other artisanal soaps on the market. What makes these bars stand out is their hardness, as they are cured for weeks to ensure a long-lasting bar.

From my experience, the bar lasted me about three weeks of daily use, which is slightly longer than Dr. Squatch soaps I’ve used in the past. The company claims you can get 21+ showers from one bar, which seems accurate if you store it properly in a dry soap dish. The durability is impressive compared to softer soaps that tend to melt away quickly, making The Black Stuff a better long-term option for those who want a more resilient bar.

However, I did notice that if you don’t keep the bar dry between uses, it can start to dissolve faster. So, a good soap dish is essential if you want to maximize its lifespan.

Brand Reputation

The Black Stuff is a small, independent brand from Ireland, founded by soap artisan John Larkin. Their focus on natural ingredients and handcrafted quality is evident in their products. The brand has a dedicated following, with many customers praising their unique scents and long-lasting bars.

One of the things I appreciate about this brand is their transparency. They provide clear information about their ingredients and manufacturing practices. The fact that they are vegan-friendly and palm oil-free shows their commitment to ethical production.

Customer reviews are generally positive, with people highlighting the quality, scent, and effectiveness of the soap. The brand also has a strong social media presence, where they engage with their community and share updates about new products and offers.

Price and Value

The price of The Black Stuff soap ranges from $7.75 to $9.50 per bar, depending on the variety and whether you buy them individually or in bundles. While it’s not the cheapest soap on the market, the quality and longevity justify the cost.

They offer bundle deals and occasional discounts, which can help you save if you plan to stock up. There’s also a subscription option on their website for those who want regular deliveries.

Compared to other artisan soaps, The Black Stuff is reasonably priced. Considering the natural ingredients, handcrafted process, and long-lasting bars, I think it offers good value for money.

Availability

The Black Stuff soaps are primarily available online through their official website and Amazon. While you might find them in some specialty stores, they aren’t widely available in regular retail outlets.

Shipping costs and times vary depending on your location, but the company does offer free shipping on certain orders. They also occasionally release limited edition scents, so it’s worth keeping an eye on their website.

Pros & Cons

REASONS TO BUY
  • All-natural ingredients
  • Vegan-friendly and palm oil-free
  • Unique, long-lasting scents
  • Handcrafted in small batches
  • Durable and long-lasting bars
REASONS TO AVOID
  • Not widely available in stores
  • Price may be high for some
  • Needs proper storage to last longer
check price

Overall Rating

Overall, I would give The Black Stuff All Natural Bar Soap a solid 9/10. It ticks a lot of boxes: natural ingredients, unique scents, and great lather. While it may not be the cheapest option out there, the quality and longevity make it worth the investment.

If you’re looking for a masculine, all-natural soap that’s gentle on the skin but tough on dirt, I highly recommend giving The Black Stuff a try. Just make sure you’ve got a good soap dish to keep it dry between uses!

Add Comment