An Honest Review of Amish Farms Moisturizing Bar Soap (2025)

When it comes to skincare, I’ve always been drawn to products that emphasize natural ingredients. So, when I came across Amish Farms Moisturizing Bar Soap, I was intrigued. Known for its handmade quality and focus on natural, eco-friendly practices, this soap seemed to check a lot of boxes. It gained additional attention after being featured by cooking personality Brenda Gantt, which piqued my curiosity even more. Marketed as vegan, cruelty-free, and hypoallergenic, it promised suitability for sensitive skin. After several weeks of use, I’m here to share my honest thoughts — the good, the bad, and everything in between.

amish farms bar soap bag pack

Packaging

The first thing that stood out to me was the simple and eco-conscious packaging. Each soap bar comes in recyclable materials, with options for single bars, 3-bar bags, 5-bar bags, and 6-bar boxes. The bags are made from plastic pouches, while the boxes contain individually wrapped soap pieces. I appreciated the practical and minimalistic approach, avoiding unnecessary plastic or flashy designs. However, the packaging might feel a bit plain if you’re someone who enjoys a luxurious unboxing experience. The variety packs also come in random colors, which adds a fun surprise element but might not appeal to those who prefer uniformity.

Ingredients

As someone who carefully considers what goes on my skin, the ingredient list was a major highlight. Amish Farms soap is crafted using natural components like coconut oil, shea butter, castor oil, and bentonite clay. These ingredients are well-known for their moisturizing and cleansing properties. Additionally, the soap is free of parabens, sulfates, gluten, and artificial fragrances, which is a big plus for those avoiding harsh chemicals. However, it’s worth noting that some traditional variants include tallow (rendered animal fat), so strict vegans should verify their purchase. Although lye is used in the saponification process, it’s fully neutralized in the final product, as is standard for handmade soaps.

Scent

One of the most delightful aspects of this soap is its variety of scents. From lavender to oatmeal, citrus to peppermint, there’s something for everyone. I personally tried the Wildflower scent, which I found light, clean, and refreshing without being overpowering. However, scent preferences are subjective, and some users describe the Wildflower scent as slightly “soapy” or perfumed. Fortunately, there’s an unscented version available for those with fragrance sensitivities, which I think is a thoughtful inclusion.

Effectiveness

When it comes to performance, Amish Farms Moisturizing Bar Soap truly delivers. Its cleansing power is impressive; it effectively removes dirt, oil, and even light makeup without leaving my skin feeling dry or stripped. The soap creates a rich, creamy lather that feels luxurious, even in areas with hard water. Thanks to its natural glycerin content and moisturizing oils, my skin felt soft and hydrated after every use. It’s also gentle enough for sensitive skin, which is a major plus for me as someone prone to occasional irritation.

color and shape of amish farms bar soap

My husband has even used this soap for shaving, and it worked surprisingly well, providing enough slip and moisture. However, I’ve read that lathering might be slightly reduced in very hard water, so results may vary depending on your water type.

Size and Lifespan

One of the standout features of Amish Farms soap is its generous size. Each bar often exceeds the stated weight of 5 ounces, making it larger than most standard soaps. The dense composition and long curing process ensure the bars last a long time, even with daily use. I found that one bar easily lasted several weeks, adding to its overall value. However, the larger size can feel a bit unwieldy when new, though this becomes less of an issue as the bar is used.

Brand Reputation

Amish Farms has earned a solid reputation over its 30 years of operation. As a family-owned business, they prioritize sustainable practices and source their ingredients from local farms whenever possible. Their commitment to traditional methods, like the cold-process technique, adds authenticity to their products. While the brand name draws inspiration from Amish traditions, it’s unclear if the soaps are directly made by Amish communities, which may be worth noting for some buyers.

Price and Value

In terms of cost, Amish Farms soap is affordable and a great value. Unlike many boutique soaps, it is priced comparably to standard mass-market options while offering superior quality. You can purchase single bars or multi-packs, with the latter offering even better value. For example, a 5-bar bag of random color bars costs around $10, and free shipping is available for orders over $60. Considering the size, effectiveness, and natural ingredients, this soap is an excellent choice for anyone seeking quality skincare on a budget.

Availability

One drawback is that Amish Farms soap isn’t always easy to find in physical stores. It’s primarily available online or at select local markets, particularly in areas with Amish communities. This could be inconvenient for those who prefer in-person shopping or need the product quickly. That said, the wide availability through online retailers ensures most people can access it with ease.

REASONS TO BUY
  • Handmade with natural ingredients
  • Free of harsh chemicals and allergens
  • Variety of pleasant scents
  • Large, long-lasting bars
  • Gentle and moisturizing, suitable for sensitive skin
REASONS TO AVOID
  • Limited availability in physical stores
  • Scent preferences may vary
  • Doesn’t lather as well in very hard water
check price

Overall Rating

After weeks of using Amish Farms Moisturizing Bar Soap, I’m genuinely impressed. It strikes an excellent balance between effectiveness, sustainability, and affordability. While it has a few minor drawbacks, the positives far outweigh them. I would confidently rate this soap a solid 4.5 out of 5 stars. Whether you’re looking for a natural soap to soothe sensitive skin or a long-lasting bar that provides good value, Amish Farms is definitely worth trying.

Add Comment