My Honest Review of Malin + Goetz Bar Soap (2025)

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our full disclosure here.

When it comes to bar soaps, I tend to look for a balance between effective cleansing, skin comfort, and an enjoyable sensory experience. After hearing quite a bit about Malin + Goetz Bar Soaps, I decided to give them a try, specifically the Rum Bar Soap, which is one of their signature scents. Malin + Goetz positions itself as a luxury yet minimalist skincare brand that emphasizes gentle formulations, sleek packaging, and modern design. After using the soap for several weeks, I’ve gathered my honest impressions, covering both its strengths and areas where it may fall short.

Packaging

The first thing that struck me about this soap was its minimalist packaging. It comes in a 100% recyclable cardboard box, simple yet elegant, reflecting the brand’s eco-conscious philosophy. The design is very modern and apothecary-like, with clean typography and subtle color coding to indicate the scent (in my case, yellow for Rum). It feels gender-neutral and would look right at home in any minimalist bathroom setup.

The box clearly lists the brand, product name, scent, full ingredient list, and size (5 oz / 140g). I liked how straightforward and legible everything was—no overcomplication, just the essentials. The packaging gives off a luxury everyday use vibe while remaining practical and easy to store. I also appreciated that the soap itself was a smooth, rectangular off-white bar with rounded edges, which felt nice in the hand and was comfortable to hold while showering.

Ingredients

Malin + Goetz uses a mix of natural ingredients and gentle synthetic agents, staying true to their philosophy of “less, but better.” Key cleansing agents include Sodium Palmate and Sodium Palm Kernelate, while Glycerin provides hydration. The soap is free from sulfates, parabens, phthalates, and synthetic fragrances, which makes it suitable for sensitive skin.

Another point I appreciated is that the brand is cruelty-free and Leaping Bunny certified. While not certified organic, the formulas are pH-balanced and designed to be mild. That said, it does contain palm oil derivatives, though the brand assures that they use RSPO-certified sustainable sources. As someone who tries to be environmentally conscious, this transparency matters to me. The ingredient list is also very straightforward, without unnecessary fillers—just what you need for a quality cleansing bar.

Scent

The Rum scent was the highlight for me. It’s warm, slightly sweet, and sophisticated—different from the usual citrus or herbal scents I often find in soaps. The fragrance is moderate in strength: noticeable while lathering and in the shower, but it doesn’t linger heavily on the skin afterward. This works well for me since I don’t like strong scents clashing with my cologne.

Malin + Goetz also offers other scents like Peppermint (refreshing and cooling) and Lime (bright and zesty). From reviews I’ve seen, Peppermint is a fan favorite, but I personally loved the Rum for its cozy, spa-like quality, especially in cooler months. I noticed how the fragrance filled the steam of my shower, making the whole bathroom smell inviting for a short while, but without leaving an overpowering trail.

Lather and Application

This soap produces a dense, creamy lather rather than light, airy bubbles. It spreads easily across the skin and rinses off cleanly without leaving residue. I found it very pleasant to use—it has that “luxury soap” feel where you don’t need much to cover the entire body. The bar is solid, easy to grip, and doesn’t get overly slippery, which is a plus.

Another thing worth mentioning: my husband actually tried using it as a shaving soap in a pinch and said the creamy lather worked surprisingly well for that purpose, offering decent slip for the razor. I also found that it worked well regardless of water type—whether in softer or harder water, the lather stayed rich and rinsed away smoothly.

Effectiveness

In terms of performance, the Malin + Goetz Bar Soap is highly effective at cleansing without leaving my skin dry or tight. I often describe it as a “squeaky clean without the stripping” effect. My skin felt balanced, smooth, and refreshed after every use. Unlike some moisturizing bars that leave a film, this one rinsed off completely, which I really liked.

It’s not an exfoliating soap, so if you’re looking for scrubbing power, this won’t deliver that. But as a daily cleanser, it does an excellent job. I also didn’t experience any irritation or clogged pores, making it a great option for sensitive or combination skin. The gentle formula left my skin feeling calm, and I even found it suitable for both morning and evening showers.

Size and Lifespan

The soap comes in a standard 5 oz (140g) size, which is fairly typical for premium bar soaps. What sets it apart is that it is triple-milled, making the bar dense, hard, and long-lasting. Even with daily use, it held up much longer than many softer soaps I’ve tried in the past. It didn’t turn mushy or break apart, which I appreciated. To get the most out of it, I stored it on a well-draining soap dish away from direct water streams. With proper care, it lasted several weeks without noticeably shrinking too quickly. I liked that it didn’t leave any soap scum or staining in the shower, which made it even more practical for everyday use.

Brand Reputation

Malin + Goetz is a family-owned brand, founded in 2004 in New York City by Matthew Malin and Andrew Goetz. The company has built a strong reputation for creating simple, high-quality, unisex skincare and fragrance products that work well even for sensitive skin. Their products are made in the USA and are known for being cruelty-free and thoughtfully formulated.

The brand is also praised for its sustainability practices, such as recyclable packaging and sourcing palm oil from RSPO-certified suppliers. They’ve received recognition in beauty and lifestyle publications like Allure and GQ, and customer reviews are generally positive, with many praising the soaps’ scents and gentle formulas. I also liked how open the company is about its ingredient philosophy—this kind of transparency helps build trust. The main critique I often come across is the high price point.

Price and Value

At around $16–$18 per bar, Malin + Goetz Bar Soaps definitely sit in the luxury category. Compared to drugstore soaps, the price is steep. However, when you consider its triple-milled durability, skin-friendly formulation, cruelty-free certification, and overall experience, it starts to feel more justified. I would still categorize it as a treat or indulgence, rather than an everyday staple for everyone. It also makes a thoughtful gift because of its unisex design and sophisticated presentation. I could see it being a safe choice for housewarmings or small occasions where you want something both practical and a little indulgent.

Availability

One of the nice things about Malin + Goetz is that their products are fairly easy to find for a premium brand. They are sold through the official website, department stores like Nordstrom and Bloomingdale’s, online retailers such as Sephora and Amazon, and even stocked in some boutique apothecaries. I also found that it’s a popular choice as an amenity in upscale hotels. So while the brand positions itself as niche and high-end, accessibility isn’t really an issue. During sales events like the Nordstrom Anniversary Sale, I’ve noticed you can even grab these at a slightly better price, which makes stocking up a little more appealing.

Overall Rating