Looking for a Honey Substitute? Check out these 10 Choices

As people become more conscious about their diet and food choices, the search for healthier alternatives has surged particularly high. Although honey is a natural sweetener well-known for its health benefits, some people may seek alternatives due to its high sugar content, dietary preferences, or allergies. Not to worry, there are plenty of honey substitutes around to sweeten your meals. Here, we guide you through 10 amazing alternatives to honey.

substitutes for honey

1. Maple Syrup

Best known as the perfect pancake topper, maple syrup is a natural sweetener derived straight from the sap of the sugar, red, and black maple trees. More than just a table-top sweetener, it boasts a unique decadent, caramel-like flavor that is hard to compete with. Thanks to its abundance of minerals like calcium and potassium and a good dose of antioxidants, maple syrup is not just delicious; it’s healthy too.

maple syrup

While the market may be awash with various types of maple syrup, the natural ones stand head and shoulders above the rest thanks to their less processed state, preserving the beneficial nutrients. In addition, maple syrup is known to help regulate blood sugar levels and can easily be used to replace honey in a multitude of recipes, making it not only a sweet syrup but a versatile kitchen item too.

2. Agave Nectar

agave nectar

When it comes to satisfying your sweet tooth without honey, agave nectar is an excellent choice. Made from the sap of the blue agave plant, agave nectar sports a similar sweetness level and viscosity as honey, making it a direct swap in any recipe. What sets it apart is its low glycemic index, making it a great option for those keeping an eye on their blood sugar levels. Plus, the absence of any animal products in its composition makes it a great vegan pick.

3. Date Paste

date paste

One of the key advantages of date paste is that you aren’t restricted to a specific date variety. The readily available standard type found in most supermarket aisles works just as well. Additionally, the paste is very simple to make at home. Soak the pitted dates in water overnight, then blend them in your food processor until you reach your desired consistency. For a bit of flair, consider adding flavorings like vanilla or lemon! With its rich amount of nutrients, it goes beyond just replacing sweetness but adds an extra health punch to your meals.

4. Apple Sauce

apple sauce

Apple sauce emerges as a top contender when one seeks a healthy substitute for honey, especially in baking. Interestingly, it can also substitute other ingredients, such as oil or butter in recipes, due to its moist, smooth texture. However, it may not be the best fit for cookies and similar crunchy baked goods due to this texture. Beyond this, apples are rich in important antioxidants, dietary fiber, and vitamin C. For those interested in a low-sugar option, unsweetened apple sauce is a viable choice.

5. Brown Rice Syrup

Although not as sweet as honey, brown rice syrup boasts a distinct, earthy flavor that enriches both cooked dishes and baked goods. This thick, dark syrup is derived from brown rice that has been cooked and then fermented with enzymes, a process that breaks down the starches. This results in a versatile syrup appropriate for a range of dishes.

brown rice syrup
Credits: Jesse M Sydney

Brown rice syrup is cherished for its texture — it’s slightly stickier than honey, making it particularly suitable for certain dishes. On the downside though, because of its lower sweetness, achieving the same sweetness level as honey may necessitate using it in larger quantities. People with diabetes must use it sparingly or refrain from it due to its high glycemic index, which could potentially trigger an undesirable surge in blood sugar levels.

6. Coconut Nectar

coconut nectar
Credits: Joyce Nai

For those with a soft spot for coconut, the tropical flavor of coconut nectar makes it a wonderful honey alternative. It’s derived from the sap of the coconut palm tree, providing a unique twist in flavor. Its thick and creamy texture closely mirrors that of honey, making it useful in a multitude of dishes. Moreover, coconut nectar boasts a low glycemic index and is loaded with minerals and vitamins, including potassium, zinc, iron, and vitamin C.

7. Molasses

Molasses is a thick, dark syrup made as a byproduct during the sugar-making process. Its strong, full-bodied flavor carries hints of bitterness, offering a deep complexity that can enhance a range of dishes.

Credits: Chris Waits

Molasses holds a special place in baking, particularly in holiday treats – who doesn’t love those delightfully sticky gingerbread cookies? You might also find it playing a starring role in food products like barbecue sauces. A varied palette of molasses types, each with its unique flavor notes, enriches its culinary versatility. Most importantly, its nutritional profile surpasses many of its counterparts. It’s abundant in several essential vitamins and minerals such as iron, calcium, magnesium, and vitamin B6.

8. Yacon Root Syrup

Yacon root syrup is a less-known but valuable honey substitute. Hailing from the Yacon plant native to South America, this syrup is praised for its health benefits. Its taste is sweet, a bit earthy, with a touch of apple and perhaps a hint of floral. Yacon root syrup is low in calories and has a low glycemic index, which is good news for those watching their weight or sugar intake. Studies show that it may also aid gut health due to its high FOS (fructooligosaccharides) content.

yacon root syrup
Credits: Krisna Prado

However, Yacon root syrup is best used uncooked, as cooking may break down its insoluble fibers, limiting its health benefits. Highlighted for its blood sugar and blood pressure regulation properties, Yacon is more than just a sweetener – it’s a health booster.

9. Barley Malt Syrup

With a taste reminiscent of molasses yet more mellow, and complemented by a malty undertone, barley malt syrup offers a distinctive alternative to honey. This syrup is produced by malting barley grains until they create a sweet substance. Although barley malt syrup is less sweet than honey, its full-bodied flavor serves as a fantastic enhancer in baking—particularly in breads and other savory dishes.

While many people favor barley malt syrup for its malted flavor, it does have a slightly lower sweetness level compared to table sugar, which may necessitate using more of it in recipes. Additionally, it contains a significant amount of maltose, making mindful consumption crucial. Nonetheless, its rich array of micronutrients makes barley malt syrup a well-rounded, healthy, and delicious alternative.

10. Corn Syrup

corn syrup
Credits: Ut Lun Kute

Corn syrup, available mainly in light and dark variants, offers a wide applicability range in cooking and baking. From cookies to candies, this syrup adds sweetness without crystallization, a problem often encountered with some syrups. Dark corn syrup, with a flavor profile similar to molasses, is even used in barbeque sauces. As a side perk, corn syrup may help maintain the freshness of cooked food longer. However, owing to its high fructose content, it’s best to use this sweetener in moderation.

In conclusion, taking the step to switch from honey to an alternative sweetener is a personal choice that can be based on health, flavor preference, or ethical reasons. Each honey substitute listed offers unique tastes and health benefits. So, feel free to experiment until you find the perfect alternative that adds that sweet touch to your meals while suiting your dietary needs or preferences. It’s not only about replacing honey but discovering new flavors and adding nutritional diversity to your diet.

Add Comment